Case file — White County Circuit Court

73CV-26-287

Lynch v. White County et al.

70 filed documents from the state-court case: the complaint, IFP papers, the three recusal orders, judicial appointment orders, the appellate briefs, the Rule 60 indicative-ruling motion, and the record compilation. More documents will be posted as they are scanned.

Complaint / Petition (filed)

Complaint and petition filed in forma pauperis on February 23, 2026.

View / download

Affidavit in Forma Pauperis

IFP affidavit filed with the complaint on February 23, 2026.

View / download

Order to Proceed In Forma Pauperis

April 1, 2026 order granting leave to proceed IFP.

View / download

Original Filing Notice

April 1, 2026 notice reflecting the original filing.

View / download

Order of Recusal — Judge Pate

February 24, 2026 recusal order, the first of three in the opening week.

View / download

Order of Recusal — Judge Brock

February 25, 2026 recusal order.

View / download

Order of Recusal — Judge Hannah

February 25, 2026 recusal order.

View / download

Order Appointing Counsel — Hon. Bentley E. Story

March 3, 2026 Supreme Court of Arkansas order (No. 26-126) assigning retired Circuit Judge Bentley E. Story to the case.

View / download

Termination Order — Hon. Bentley E. Story

March 12, 2026 Supreme Court of Arkansas order (No. 26-150) granting the motion for termination of Judge Story's assignment, at Judge Story's request.

View / download

Order Appointing — Hon. Robert Bynum Gibson Jr.

March 20, 2026 order assigning the presiding judge.

View / download

Briefing Schedule

Briefing schedule entered in the appeal.

View / download

Appellant's Brief — CV-26-301 (Circuit Court Case No. 73CV-26-287)

Appellant's brief filed in the related appeal, CV-26-301.

View / download

Appellant's Brief — Cover

Cover of the appellant's brief.

View / download

Appellant's Brief — Page Rewrite

Revised page(s) of the appellant's brief.

View / download

Appellant's Brief — Revised

Revised appellant's brief.

View / download

Amended and Substitute Brief of Appellant

Amended and substitute brief of appellant filed June 18, 2026.

View / download

Amended and Substitute Brief of Appellant — Supreme Court Filing (July 20, 2026)

34-page amended and substitute brief filed directly with the Arkansas Supreme Court (CV-26-301) on July 20, 2026.

View / download

Supplemental Notice

Supplemental notice filed in the case.

View / download

Motion for Indicative Ruling (Rule 60)

Motion for indicative ruling, brief-style filing.

View / download

Entire Record — Lynch v. White County

Compilation of the record in Lynch v. White County.

View / download

Supplemental Argument Regarding Improper Dismissal

Supplemental argument filed after the case was closed, addressing the dismissal.

View / download

Additional Notice of Appeal and Supplemental Statement of Issues

Additional notice of appeal with a supplemental statement of the issues, filed June 2026.

View / download

Motion to Set Aside Order of Dismissal

Motion asking the circuit court to set aside its order of dismissal.

View / download

Notice of Supplemental Authority

Notice of supplemental authority and concern regarding subsequent proceedings below.

View / download

Supplemental Notice to the Court

Supplemental notice to the court regarding the proceedings.

View / download

Formal Order — Arkansas Supreme Court (June 4, 2026)

CV-26-301: appellant's pro se second motion to expedite review denied; Womack, J., would moot; Webb, J., not participating. Filed June 9, 2026.

View / download

Pick-Up Order

April 7, 2026 order directing FCI El Reno to surrender Mr. Lynch to the White County Sheriff for court proceedings on May 14, 2026.

View / download

Notice to the Court Regarding Prior Federal Intervention and Impropriety of Return to White County Custody

Dated April 9, 2026, filed April 20, 2026 — notice detailing the prior federal-court interventions, ongoing retaliation and medical-neglect concerns, and why any writ or return to White County Jail custody would be improper.

View / download

Emergency Notice re Civil Writ — Safety and Custody Concerns

Dated April 11, 2026, filed April 17, 2026 — analysis of the constitutional protections (Eighth, First, and Fourteenth Amendments; 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981, 1983, 1985) implicated by any civil writ returning Mr. Lynch to White County custody while his federal claims are pending.

View / download

Emergency Notice and Request for Stay, Continuance, and to Quash Civil Writ

April 2026 — emergency request to stay the state proceedings, continue any hearing, and quash the civil writ ordering Mr. Lynch's transport from federal custody.

View / download

Emergency Motion for Temporary Protective Order

April 2026 — motion seeking protection against transfer back to White County custody during the pendency of the federal civil-rights actions.

View / download

Addendum to Emergency Motion for Protective Order and Injunctive Relief

Supplement to the emergency protective-order motion, adding supporting grounds for injunctive relief.

View / download

Emergency Motion to Recall/Quash Writ, for Protective Order, and for Stay of Proceedings

Dated April 11, 2026, filed April 15, 2026 — emergency motion to stop the unlawful transfer of Mr. Lynch to White County Jail and protect his life, health, and safety.

View / download

Emergency Notice to the Court

April 2026 — emergency notice alerting the court to the safety and custody concerns surrounding the civil writ.

View / download

Notice of Appeal

Filed April 17, 2026 — the first notice of appeal from the trial-setting and related interlocutory orders.

View / download

Designation of Record on Appeal

April 2026 — designation of the record to be transmitted for appellate review.

View / download

Letter to the Court

Correspondence to the court concerning the emergency filings and the writ/transport issue.

View / download

Emergency Petition for Writ of Mandamus/Prohibition and Stay

April 2026 — petition to the Arkansas appellate courts for extraordinary writ relief and a stay of the circuit court proceedings.

View / download

Emergency Appeal — Motion for Immediate Stay and Petition for Writ of Mandamus

April 2026 — combined emergency appeal motion seeking an immediate stay and mandamus relief.

View / download

Emergency Supporting Brief and Memorandum of Law in Support of Petition for Writ of Mandamus and Emergency Appeal

Dated April 12, 2026, filed April 17, 2026 — supporting brief arguing the circuit court bypassed mandatory rules of procedure, set trial without service or discovery, and created an unconstitutional 'trial by surprise.'

View / download

Emergency Summary Sheet

Summary sheet accompanying the emergency appellate filings.

View / download

Motion for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pauperis (28 U.S.C. § 1915) — Scanned Filing

Stamped filed February 23, 2026 — the IFP motion submitted with the original complaint, with affidavit and certified inmate account statement.

View / download

Supporting Brief Part 1 — Opening Statement and Total Case Summary

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — jury-addressed opening statement and comprehensive case summary in support of the state-law violations and tort claims.

View / download

Supporting Brief Part 15 — Declaratory and Injunctive Relief

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — remedial, equity-focused argument under the Arkansas Declaratory Judgment Act (Ark. Code Ann. § 16-111-101 et seq.) and supplemental federal authority.

View / download

Medical Addendum re Jason Matthew Lynch

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — clinical summary of Mr. Lynch's documented medical decline, the interruption of antiretroviral therapy, and why judicial intervention is medically necessary.

View / download

Super Case Summary

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — master executive case summary combining the legal filings, medical documentation, case facts, and constitutional violations across the state and federal matters.

View / download

Pro Se Motion for Judicial Recusal (Recusal & Venue Change Part 1)

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — motion for mandatory judicial recusal of the presiding White County Circuit Court judge and for a ruling on the change-of-venue motion by a new or associate judge.

View / download

Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Judicial Disqualification / Recusal and Change of Venue (Part 2)

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — stand-alone memorandum applying the federal and Arkansas recusal authorities (28 U.S.C. §§ 144, 455) to Mr. Lynch's state and federal matters.

View / download

Affidavit of Jason Matthew Lynch in Support of Judicial Disqualification / Recusal and Change of Venue (Part 3)

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — affidavit of bias and prejudice under 28 U.S.C. §§ 144 and 455, sworn under penalty of perjury pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746.

View / download

Memorandum of Law in Support of Mandatory Judicial Disqualification and Recusal in All Proceedings

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — brief arguing disqualification is mandatory in all White County proceedings involving Mr. Lynch under 28 U.S.C. §§ 144 and 455 and corresponding Arkansas authorities.

View / download

Motion for Order Compelling Preservation of All Evidence (Filed Prior to Any Venue Change)

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — pre-trial emergency motion to preserve all evidence in Defendants' possession, filed before any venue change so critical evidence is not destroyed, altered, concealed, or lost.

View / download

Motion for Order Compelling Preservation of All Evidence

Filed May 8, 2026 — emergency motion to preserve all evidence in Defendants' possession.

View / download

Motion for Leave to Conduct Limited Discovery to Identify Doe Defendants

Filed May 8, 2026 — targeted request for duty rosters and shift-assignment logs to name Doe defendants.

View / download

Formal Order — Arkansas Supreme Court (May 5, 2026)

CV-26-301: appellant's pro se motion to expedite review denied; Wood, J., would order a response and stay briefing. Filed May 11, 2026.

View / download

Omnibus Notice and Motion to Supplement the Record

Filed May 14, 2026 — motion for leave to supplement the record with certified copies of the orders being appealed, and notice of obstruction by the White County Circuit Clerk's Office.

View / download

Notice of Change of Address

Filed May 15, 2026 — notice of new mailing address in Ward, Arkansas, following release and reentry.

View / download

First Additional Supplemental to Claims

Filed May 26, 2026 — supplements state-law claims arising from Defendants' failure to transport Mr. Lynch to mandatory civil court proceedings, with resulting default judgments and losses estimated above $75,000.

View / download

Order of Dismissal (June 5, 2026)

Order dismissing the petition for failure to appear at the May 14, 2026 hearing — the same hearing for which the April 7 pick-up order issued.

View / download

Brief of Appellant — CV-26-301

40-page brief of appellant filed June 8, 2026 in the Arkansas Supreme Court appeal.

View / download

Second Notice of Appeal

Second notice of appeal filed following the post-dismissal rulings, expanding the issues taken up to the Arkansas appellate courts.

View / download

Emergency Motion for Expedited Appeal and for Writ of Mandamus and/or Prohibition

Emergency motion asking the Arkansas Supreme Court to expedite the appeal and issue extraordinary writ relief concerning the proceedings below.

View / download

Memorandum of Law in Support of Emergency Appeal and Petition for Writ of Mandamus

Supporting memorandum setting out the legal grounds for expedited appellate review and mandamus relief.

View / download

Appellee's Brief

Defendants' response brief in the CV-26-301 appeal, filed June 27, 2026.

View / download

Order Setting Trial Date (April 7, 2026)

Order setting the final hearing for May 14, 2026, 9:00 a.m.–12:00 p.m., Courtroom #3, White County Justice Center — entered while Mr. Lynch was in federal custody at FCI El Reno.

View / download

Plaintiff's Objection to Scheduling Order and Order for Writ; Motion to Recall and Set Aside Writ; Request for Stay

Filed April 9, 2026 (8 pages) — objection that the scheduling order and writ violate due process, bypass mandatory procedural safeguards, and create substantial risk of irreparable harm.

View / download

Motion to Stay Proceedings for 30 Days

Filed April 9, 2026 (11 pages) — request for a temporary stay given Mr. Lynch's custody at FCI El Reno and imminent transition to home confinement, requiring travel and coordination with federal authorities.

View / download

Closing Statement

Stamped filed April 1, 2026 — closing argument: not a single mistake but a pattern of ignored medical orders, deflected responsibility between White County and Turn Key Health, and retaliatory enforcement of silence.

View / download

Supporting Brief Part 16 — History of White County, Turn Key Health Clinics, and Clayton Edwards

Filed April 1, 2026 — documented pattern and practice: Turn Key's litigation history (at least 160 lawsuits between 2015 and 2023), documented deaths in custody, and systemic misconduct relevant under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and Monell.

View / download

Supporting Brief Part 18 — Comprehensive Timeline of Events, Actors, and Known Conduct

Filed April 1, 2026 — chronological, actor-specific timeline from pre-incarceration medical status (HIV-positive, stable on Biktarvy) through the events giving rise to the federal and state claims.

View / download

Supporting Brief Part 19 — Damages

Filed April 1, 2026 — categories of harm: denial and interruption of antiretroviral HIV medication, forced medication lapses causing viral rebound and resistance risk, permanent complications, and the legal basis for compensatory, enhanced, and punitive damages.

View / download
Full entries on the state docket page · background on the state case page · ← All case files